Gulf damage will last 'for years if not decades'

Oil spill will have ripple effects far into the future, scientists warn

Oil spill disaster in the Gulf
Following a deadly oil rig explosion, crews attempt to contain an underwater oil well gushing thousands of gallons a day, fouling the water and coastline.

Florida beaches open amid cleanup
June 5: Along the beaches of the Florida Panhandle, workers and angry residents are picking up tar balls and cleaning up oil. NBC’s Mark Potter reports.

Obama meets with business owners affected by spill
June 5: On his third trip to Louisiana since the oil spill began, President Obama kept the heat on BP, while at the same time trying to cool the anger of Gulf residents.

The Washington Post
At least $500 million has been spent since 9/11 on renovating Guantanamo Bay

Veteran reporter retires over Israel comments
Gunman kills 4 women at Florida restaurant
Jobs unveils iPhone 4 with HD video recording
N.J. man held at JFK: I'll outdo Fort Hood killer
In Florida, oil adds to economic woes
Most viewed on msnbc.com
Joint Chiefs chairman pays tribute to D-Day fallen
NY to pay 'Mafia cop' victim record $9.9 million
FBI joins search for missing Oregon boy
Dutch man sent to Peru to face murder charges
Melanoma drug cuts death risk in major trial
Most viewed on msnbc.com
Jobs unveils iPhone 4 with HD video recording
Here’s the beef: A 198-pound burger
Chrysler recalls almost 700,000 vehicles
5 steps to protect your 401(k)
Too much care? Up to 1 in 3 tests unneeded
Most viewed on msnbc.com
By Joel Achenbach and David Brown

updated 4:57 a.m. ET, Sun., June 6, 2010
Snorkeling along a coral reef near Veracruz, Mexico, in 2002, Texas biologist Wes Tunnell spotted what looked like a ledge of rock covered in sand, shells, algae and hermit crabs. He knew, from years of research at the reef, that it probably wasn't a rock at all. He stabbed it with his diving knife. His blade pulled up gunk.

"Sure enough, it was tar from the Ixtoc spill," Tunnell said.

Twenty-three years earlier, in 1979, an oil well named Ixtoc I had a blowout in 150 feet of water in the southern Gulf of Mexico. The Mexican national oil company Pemex tried to kill the well with drilling mud, and then with steel and lead balls dropped into the wellbore. It tried to contain the oil with a cap nicknamed The Sombrero. Finally, after 290 days, a relief well plugged the hole with cement and the spill came to an end — but only after polluting the gulf with 138 million gallons of crude.

That remains the worst accidental oil spill in history — but the Deepwater Horizon blowout off the Louisiana coast is rapidly gaining on it.

The spill has now been partially contained with the cap that BP engineers lowered onto the mile-deep geyser Thursday night. That means roughly a quarter to half of the flow is being piped to a surface ship, the national incident commander, Coast Guard Adm. Thad Allen, said Saturday. BP hopes to improve the rate captured in coming days. If official government estimates are correct, 23 million to 47 million gallons of oil have spewed so far.

Ripple effects

Ecosystems can survive and eventually recover from very large oil spills, even ones that are Ixtoc-sized. In most spills, the volatile compounds evaporate. The sun breaks down others. Some compounds are dissolved in water. Microbes consume the simpler, "straight chain" hydrocarbons — and the warmer it is, the more they eat. The gulf spill has climate in its favor. Scientists agree: Horrible as the spill may be, it's not going to turn the Gulf of Mexico into another Dead Sea.

But neither is this ecological crisis going to be over anytime soon. The spill will have ripple effects far into the future, scientists warn.

"This spill will be lasting for years if not decades," said Doug Inkley, senior scientist at the National Wildlife Federation.

Some of the immediate effects of a spill are obvious — witness the gut-wrenching images of soaked and suffocating seabirds in the gulf. But some types of ecological damage are hard to measure and can take years to document. Many of the creatures that die will sink to the bottom, making mortality estimates difficult. Damage to the reproduction rate of sea turtles may take years to play out.

Containment cap appears to cut flow of oil
June 5: BP’s latest efforts to contain the Gulf Oil spill appear to be working: Oil is still leaking, but the cap seems to be minimizing the flow of oil.

The Exxon Valdez spill of 11 million gallons killed as many as 700,000 sea birds and 5,000 sea otters initially, but even 21 years later, populations of sea otters in areas of Prince William Sound haven't recovered. The Pacific herring population collapsed after the spill for reasons that remain in dispute among scientists. Two intensely studied pods of killer whales in the sound suffered heavy losses in the spill and have struggled since. One of the two pods has no more reproductive females. It is doomed to extinction.

And the oil?

"It's still sitting there," said Stan Rice, program manager for habitat studies at the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration's Auke Bay Fisheries Lab. "It's still liquid, you can still smell it and touch it."

The degradation of oil slows over the years. The microbes move on, as the large and complex compounds that remain, known as the asphaltenes, are too hard to digest. What's left tends to be dense, tar-like, largely inert and attractive only to people who like to pave roads.

By 2003, there were still 21,000 gallons of oil in Prince William Sound, Rice reports in a recently published study on the lingering effects of the Exxon Valdez spill. The oil can be found by someone scraping three to six inches below the surface of the beach. Rice writes that an oil spill will be "over" when the oil itself is gone, the litigation has been settled and there are no continued negative effects in the environment.

"The Exxon Valdez spill does not meet any of these three criteria," he wrote.


Click for related content
BP: 'Majority' of leaking oil is being captured
NYT: Who was in charge of rig? It's unclear
Oil spill's threat to wildlife turns real
NYT: Bye, limitless oil; hi, primitive dystopia?
BP investors struggle to factor in huge costs
NYT: Oil threatens pelicans saved from extinction

The oil drifting north from the Ixtoc spill not only wiped out hundreds of million of crabs on Mexican beaches but, also far to the north, managed to killed 80 percent of the segmented worms and shrimp-like crustaceans that live in the sand of Texas beaches, according to Tunnell, a biologist at Texas A&M University at Corpus Christi. But the tiny animals have rapid reproductive cycles, and in about two and a half years they had recovered, he said. Poor government funding limited research on the broader ecological impact of the spill, however: "We don't have any comprehensive, good scientific studies of what happened."

There are on record since 1970 about 1,700 spills from tankers in which at least 2,100 gallons of oil were discharged into water. Scientists have been monitoring the effects of some of them for decades, including a 189,000-gallon spill that occurred off Cape Cod in September 1969.

Five years after that spill, fiddler crabs in the oiled marsh were sluggish and reproduced poorly. In many cases they dug burrows too shallow to protect themselves over the winter.

Astonishingly, many of those problems remained 35 years later, when a graduate student, Jennifer Culbertson, surveyed the marsh. She found that the fiddler crabs reacted slowly to startling motions, apparently the result of a narcotic effect of oil that still formed a visible layer four inches below the marsh surface. (A similar clumsiness has been seen in juvenile spot fish when they chew on sediments contaminated with compounds from oil.) When the crabs burrowed down and hit the layer of 40-year-old oil, they veered horizontally.

"The marsh is still waging chemical warfare several inches below the surface," said Christopher M. Reddy, a chemist at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute in Massachusetts who helped supervise Culbertson's research.